Wolfram Alpha: 5 cons and 5 pros

Share
[Connotea] [del.icio.us] [Digg] [diigo] [Google] [LinkedIn] [Reddit] [StumbleUpon] [Email]

Is it necessary to present Wolfram Alpha, the new online research tool everybody is talking about those days? Obviously not! This is why we prefer to express our thoughts on it in 5 cons and 5 pros about Wolfram Alpha


5 cons on Wolfram Alpha

  1. Wolfram Alpha is not a search engine but a Computational Knowledge engine. What in earth does this stand for?
  2. Easy: Wolfram Alpha is not able to perform searches in an easy way. You have to put search terms with the right and correct words!

  3. What kind of information is available in Wolfram Alpha?
  4. Not a lot. Alpha is very specific. The best you can look for is mathematics, chemical compounds, dates, units or even the temperature in Madrid…Don’t get disappointed, we’ve warned you.

  5. Wolfram Alpha is not clever on the contrary to what it claims to be
  6. Information retrieval is based on a semantics and words tagging. With Alpha, if a word has not yet been tagged for one of its meanings in a context, you won’t get anything of it. What a pity! For example, try to ask it “Who discovered polonium?. It is not able to answer, while in google the same question is easily answered.

  7. Wolfram Alpha is for hype people!
  8. I mean, who is going to ask “How many roads must a man walk down before you can call him a man?” in order to have this result mentioning Bob Dylan. What if we ask “Who is Luke’s father?“, well, here goes the answer namely not much.

  9. Wolfram Alpha is not a resource for biomedical information.
  10. Despite what you’ve heard about it, Alpha doesn’t provide life science publications as novoseek does.


5 Pros on Wolfram Alpha

  1. Wolfram Alpha, this is not a search engine! It’s better.
  2. The way information is treated and presented is far from what you’ve seen and experienced until now. It is not Google nor Wikipedia. It is able to “computate” almost anything you ask it. Try solve a x^2 + b x + c = 0 for x

  3. Wolfram Alpha could revolutionize learning and searching on the internet
  4. Although it takes much to learn how to use it and obtain effective results, it could be an interesting tool for pupils, students and professors.

  5. Wolfram Alpha has some surprises and easter eggs for you to discover.
  6. Here goes the top 10 easter eggs in wolfram alpha. There may be more, it’s up to you to look for them.

  7. The Wolfram Alpha team is working hard to keep it updated.
  8. If there are some failures, be patient and for sure they’ll be fixed soon. The “Give us your feedback” box at the bottom of pages is there for you to point out these.

  9. They are working on making Wolfram Alpha more user friendly
  10. According to statements, they will release an API and more detailed search boxes in order to make searches easier.

Obviously, search engines on the internet are bringing changes and new ways of accessing information. Is this another step towards web 3.0 ?

We recommend you to read:

stay connected with novoseek

Subscribe to the RSS feed

  

3 comments ↓

#1    Wolfram Alpha: 5 cons and 5 pros « wolfram alpha blog on 06.01.09 at 1:18 pm

[...] post:  Wolfram Alpha: 5 cons and 5 pros 01 Jun 09 | [...]

#2    MedLib’s Round 1.5: the best of medical librarianship | Pharmamotion on 08.05.09 at 1:01 am

[...] students and physicians.  Speaking of search engines, Valentin from Novoseek’s blog analyzes Wolfram Alpha and highlights 5 cons and 5 pros of this novel search engine. Also, Krafty Librarian is testing UCentral for the [...]

#3    dewalt on 06.19.10 at 8:51 pm

My concern is that the information given is corrupted and slanted to a particular view, for a directed benefit, not of the user who asked the question.
This has occurred recently in November elections and continues today with blocked portions of information. These “Blocked” portions slant the user’s decisions in line with those who slanted the reported information. Currently, the only penalty for such acts, is a loss of business for their products or site.

Caveat Emptor AND use of such material sources

Leave a Comment